Summary of the options for the Cambridge Waste Water Treatment Plant Relocation project (official website)
Site 1 - Southwest corner of Landbeach
- Next to the Mere Way, a former Roman Road and now a popular amenity
- The Waterbeach New Town development has committed to use the Mere Way as a cycle route
- The Landbeach footpaths to the west of Mere Way will be blocked
- On high ground so will have the worst visual impact. There are few trees that would screen it from the village - farms in Mere Way and houses on west side of High Street will be particularly affected.
- The distinctive view of Landbeach from the A10, including its church spire, will be blocked, causing a loss of local character.
- In the Cambridge Green Belt
- The prevailing winds will carry the smell over Landbeach, Milton and Waterbeach
- The smell could affect Worts Meadow, which is a Scheduled Ancient Monument
- The smell could also affect the Milton Maize Maze, an important local attraction
- The site will affect Sunclose Farm, depriving it of Grade 1 land and making it less attractive to customers
- Pipeline to Waterbeach goes through the middle of Landbeach parish. This will destroy archaeological remains.
Site 2 - South of Butt Lane
- Affects the Mere Way as mentioned above
- Also threatens Landbeach and Milton with smells
- Close to Histon, Impington, Milton and Orchard Park
- Pipeline to Waterbeach goes through the middle of Landbeach parish
Site 3 - South of Horningsea
- Very few habitations downwind of the site or in sight of it
- In the Cambridge Green Belt
- Effluent pipeline is shorter
- Waterbeach pipeline is shorter and less environmentally damaging
- Site closer to the A14 for construction and for waste tankers
General points
- Anglian Water say that this is a Nationally Significant Infrastructure Project (NSIP) [see Wikipedia], but to meet this definition it would need to benefit 500,000 people. This seems implausible. It does not appear on the official National Infrastructure Planning list. Without this qualification it will not be allowed on the Green Belt.
- Upgrade the existing site. Should be possible, as Anglia Water's plans show the new plant taking up half the area of the old one. Would avoid all the environmental damage likely from moving the site.
- Green Belt. Anglian Water claim (CWWTPR – Site Selection Technical Summary, Mott Macdonald 2 July 2020, 4.1.4) that the Cambridge Green Belt is a non-statutory designation. Alan James of CPRE Cambridgeshire and Peterborough, in correspondence with Ray Gambell of Landbeach, 3 Sept 2020, states that this is not true: "The Cambridge Green Belt is one of the 14 statutory green belts in England."
